| Name | Year | College |
| Jacob Beall | 2021 | University of Akron |
| Grant Miller | 2021 | Ball State University |
| Carter Rust | 2021 | University of Charleston |
| Alex Jarboe | 2020 | Northwood University |
| Bradley Vargas | 2020 | Rockingham Community College |
| Michael Lorenz | 2020 | Waubonsee Community College |
| Nic Lenzer | 2020 | Centre College |
| Brandon Smith | 2019 | Wilmington College |
| Matt Brankamp | 2019 | Mount St. Joseph University |
| Keegan Fish | 2018 | Ohio State University/Drafted by the Miami Marlins in the 13th round |
| Andrew Brownley | 2018 | Otterbein University |
| Michael Medley | 2018 | Earlham College |
| Aiden Reverman | 2018 | Thomas More University |
| Craig Nixon | 2018 | Muskingum University |
| Alex Dodson | 2017 | Ohio Northern Unversity |
| Josh Harrison | 2017 | Wake Technical CC |
| Eric Hooper | 2017 | Heidelberg University |
| Jacob Kates | 2017 | High Point University |
| Noah Maurer | 2017 | Cedarville University |
| Alssan Ramsby | 2017 | Toledo |
| Chase Wullenweber | 2017 | Tusculum College |
| Dominic Schivone | 2017 | Heildelberg University |
| Corey Peters | 2017 | Earlham |
| Brennen Martin | 2017 | Lincoln Trail CC |
| Austin Allinger | 2015 | Evansville |
| Brandon Giltrow | 2015 | Wright State |
| Dallas Hall | 2015 | Miami University |
| Andrew Huser | 2015 | Seton Hill |
| Gloria Corona-Luna | 2015 | Morehead State University |
| Blaine Griffiths | 2014 | Xavier University |
| Drew Deaton | 2014 | Bellarmine |
| Grant Schuermann | 2014 | Furman University |
| Bryan Thurnauer | 2014 | Georgetown |
| Erik Hunkemoeller | 2013 | Capital University |
| Ryan Addington | 2013 | Carson Newman University |
| Ryan Ostendorf | 2013 | Wooster University |
| Malik Zuberi | 2012 | Shawnee State |
| Zak Farmer | 2012 | Walsh University |
| Davis Schafer | 2012 | Bellarmine University |
| Mike Seaman | 2012 | Trine University |
| Nick Billman | 2012 | Mt. Saint Joseph |
| Jake Wagner | 2012 | Miami-Hamilton |
| TJ Belieu | 2011 | Miami-Hamilton |
| Ben Flannery | 2010 | Mt. Saint Joseph |
| Mark Fowler | 2010 | Wabash Valley College/Wright State |
| Collin Shaw | 2010 | Mt. Saint Joseph |
| Jake May | 2010 | Coastal Carolina |
| Kyle Poole | 2010 | Malone University |
| Preston Thompson | 2010 | University of Northwestern Ohio |
| Bryan Beaver | 2009 | Miami University |
| Ricky Finley | 2009 | Sinclair State |
| Nate Smith | 2009 | Furman University |
| Tyler and Justin Vaske | 2008 | Denison College |
| Jimmy Brenneman | 2008 | Lincoln Trail Junior College/ Campbell University |
| Robert Shaw | 2008 | University of Northwestern Ohio |
| Brad Gschwind | 2007 | Miami Univ. |
| Brandon Reder | 2007 | Ohio State-Newark |
| Collin Taylor | 2007 | Eastern Michigan University |
| Dustin Huff | 2007 | Murray State |
| Dane Fienning | 2007 | University of Cincinnati |
| Bryan Post | 2007 | UC- Clermont |
| Mike Stidham | 2007 | UC- Clermont |
| Kyle Donawerth | 2006 | Miami University |
| Steve Mirizzi | 2006 | Lincoln Trail Junior College |
| Jarrad Chapman | 2005 | Urbana Univ. |
| Kyle Lucal | 2005 | Elmhurst College |
| Zach Hardesty | 2005 | Urbana Univ. |
| Josh Colliver | 2005 | Univ. of Toledo |
| Devin Mundey | 2005 | Miami-Hamilton |
| Ryan Shaw | 2004 | Morehead State Univ. |
| Steve Williams | 2004 | Wabash Valley Junior College |
| Kyle Chapman | 2003 | University of Cincinnati |
| Matt Klinker | 2003 | Furman University |
| Mike Schmidt | 2003 | Tiffin University |
| Paul Robbins | 2003 | Tiffin University |
| David Hartman | 2003 | Ohio Northern/Xavier |
| Mark Lallathin | 2003 | Miami University |
| Jon Oliver | 2002 | Wooster |
| Brad Stelzer | 2002 | Tiffin University |
| Scott Hicks | 2002 | Univ. of South Carolina Spartenburg |
| Ben Humphrey | 2002 | Olney J.C./Central Michigan Univ. |
| Brandon Beyerlein | 2001 | Marietta College |
| Bryan Davis | 2001 | Rend Lake J.C./Southern Indiana |
| Austin Rhoads | 2001 | Indiana Univ./Miami Univ. |
| Roddy Stieger | 2001 | Marshall University |
| Justin Mundt | 2000 | Mississippi Gulf Coast J.C./Northern Kentucky |
| Josh Romero | 2000 | Indiana Univ./ Univ. of Cincinnati |
| Andy Dunn | 2000 | Mt. Vernon College of the Nazarene |
| Chris Bonati | 1998 | College of Mt. Saint Joseph |
| Ryan Venturi | 1998 | Depauw University |
